Grammarly vs ProWritingAid vs Hemingway: The Brutal Truth About Writing Assistants in 2026

Here is a hard truth: nobody reads bad writing. You could have the cure for cancer in your blog post, but if it’s riddled with typos, passive voice, and sentences that drag on for three paragraphs, people will click away. Fast.

You need an editor. But human editors are expensive ($0.05/word adds up fast). So, you turn to AI.

But which one? The market is flooded. You have the giant (Grammarly), the specialist (ProWritingAid), and the purist (Hemingway). And now, with Generative AI like Claude and ChatGPT, do you even need these tools anymore?

I’ve spent the last 5 years writing millions of words—blog posts, emails, sales copy, and even a book. I have paid for premium subscriptions to all three. I have fought with their plugins. I have let them correct my grammar (and ignored them when they were wrong).

This is not a generic “features list” review. This is a battle report from the trenches. By the end of this guide, you will know exactly which tool deserves your money.

The Cheat Sheet: Who Wins?

Short on time? Here is the verdict.

Tool	Best For…	Price (Annual)	The “Vibe”
Grammarly	Everyone. Business pros, students, bloggers.	$144	Polished, safe, everywhere.
ProWritingAid	Fiction writers & long-form authors.	$120 (Lifetime option avail)	Detailed, strict, analytical.
Hemingway	Bloggers who want punchy, clear copy.	Free / $20 (Desktop App)	Minimalist, brutal.
ChatGPT / Claude	Rewriting & brainstorming.	$240	Creative, but prone to hallucinations.

1. Grammarly: The 800lb Gorilla

Verdict: The best tool for general life. If you send emails, write Slack messages, and post on LinkedIn, get this.

Grammarly is everywhere. It’s in your browser, your Word doc, your phone keyboard. It’s the “safety net” of the internet.

Why It Wins (Pros)

• Usability: It’s seamless. The red underlines are intuitive. The “tone detector” (e.g., “You sound angry”) is surprisingly helpful for avoiding office politics disasters.
• The Mobile Keyboard: This is a lifesaver. It corrects your texts and emails on the fly. No other tool does this well.
• AI Rewrite: The new “GrammarlyGO” features are solid. You can highlight a messy paragraph and say “Make this professional,” and it actually works without leaving the tab.
• Plagiarism Checker: It scans 16 billion web pages. If you hire writers, this feature alone is worth the subscription to catch lazy work.

Where It Fails (Cons)

• It Hates Style: Grammarly wants you to sound like a corporate robot. It hates slang. It hates sentence fragments (which are great for copy). It hates personality. If you follow every suggestion, your writing will be grammatically perfect and incredibly boring.
• Price: It’s expensive. $30/month if you pay monthly is steep.
• Privacy Concerns: It reads everything you type. If you’re working on top-secret IP, check your company policy.

2. ProWritingAid: The Surgeon’s Scalpel

Verdict: Essential for authors and long-form writers. Overkill for emails.

If Grammarly is a spellchecker on steroids, ProWritingAid is a writing coach. It doesn’t just look for errors; it looks for bad habits.

Why It Wins (Pros)

• Deep Analysis: It has 20+ reports. “Sticky Sentences,” “Repeated Words,” “Pacing Check.” It tells you things like, “You used the word ‘actually’ 15 times in this chapter. Stop it.”
• Scrivener Integration: If you write books in Scrivener, ProWritingAid integrates directly. Grammarly doesn’t. This is a dealbreaker for novelists.
• Lifetime Deal: Unlike the subscription-only model of Grammarly, you can buy ProWritingAid once and own it forever. That’s huge value.

Where It Fails (Cons)

• Clunky UI: It feels like software built by engineers, not designers. It can be slow with large documents.
• Not for “Quick” Writing: It’s too heavy for just writing a quick email. It’s a “sit down and edit” tool.

3. Hemingway Editor: The Minimalist

Verdict: The best tool for bloggers and copywriters who want clarity.

Named after Ernest Hemingway (famous for his simple, direct style), this tool has one goal: cut the fluff.

Why It Wins (Pros)

• The “Grade Level” Score: This is my favorite feature. It tells you the reading level of your text. Aim for Grade 6-8. If you’re at Grade 12, your writing is too complex for the web.
• Adverb Killer: It highlights adverbs in blue and tells you to delete them. It highlights passive voice in green. It forces you to write active, strong sentences.
• Free (Mostly): The web version is 100% free. The desktop app is a one-time $20 purchase.

Where It Fails (Cons)

• It’s Not a Grammar Checker: It won’t catch typos. It won’t tell you if you used “their” instead of “there.” You need to use it with Grammarly, not instead of it.
• Rigid: Sometimes, a long sentence is okay. Hemingway hates all long sentences. You have to know when to ignore it.

4. LanguageTool: The Open Source Rebel

Verdict: The best privacy-focused alternative.

If you hate the idea of a big corporation reading your texts, LanguageTool is for you. It’s open-source, supports 30+ languages (Grammarly only does English), and has a very generous free tier.

Why It Wins (Pros)

• Multilingual: It checks Spanish, French, German, and more. Grammarly is monolingual.
• Privacy: You can even host your own server if you’re paranoid.
• Price: It’s cheaper than Grammarly.

The “Hidden” Competitor: ChatGPT & Claude

We can’t talk about writing tools in 2026 without mentioning Generative AI. Why pay for Grammarly when you can paste your text into Claude and say, “Proofread this”?

The Pros: It’s free (mostly) and can do structural rewrites (“Make this paragraph funnier”).

The Cons: It hallucinates. It might change your facts. And copying/pasting is friction. Grammarly lives where you write; ChatGPT is a destination.

Head-to-Head Test: Editing a 500-Word Article

I took a rough draft of a blog post and ran it through all three. Here is what happened:

• Grammarly: Caught 12 typos and 5 punctuation errors. Suggested changing “utilize” to “use” (Good call). Score: 85/100.
• ProWritingAid: Flagged 3 “sticky sentences” that were hard to read. Found that I overused the word “just.” Score: 70/100 (Strict!).
• Hemingway: Highlighted 4 sentences as “Very hard to read.” Told me I was writing at Grade 11 level. After edits, I got it down to Grade 7.

The Takeaway: They catch different things. Grammarly catches errors; Hemingway catches complexity; ProWritingAid catches style.

Scenario Guide: Which One Fits You?

Scenario A: The Student

You have papers due. You need citations. You are broke.
Winner: Grammarly Free + Hemingway (Web). Use Grammarly to catch typos, Hemingway to make your sentences clearer. Don’t pay for Premium unless you need the plagiarism checker.

Scenario B: The Freelance Writer

You write 5,000 words a day. Time is money.
Winner: Grammarly Premium. The integration with Google Docs and WordPress saves you hours of copy-pasting. The plagiarism checker protects your reputation.

Scenario C: The Novelist

You are writing a 80,000-word manuscript.
Winner: ProWritingAid. It handles large documents better than Grammarly (which tends to crash). The “Pacing” and “Dialogue” reports are invaluable for fiction.

FAQ: What Should You Buy?

1. Is the free version of Grammarly enough?

Yes, if you are a native English speaker with decent grammar. The free version catches the embarrassing mistakes (typos, repeated words). The Premium version is for style (“delivery,” “engagement”). If you’re writing for a living, pay for Premium. If not, stick to free.

2. Can I use them together?

Absolutely. My workflow is: Draft in Google Docs -> Run Grammarly -> Paste into Hemingway App to check readability -> Publish. It takes 5 extra minutes but improves the quality by 50%.

3. Do they work for non-native speakers?

Grammarly is the best for ESL (English as a Second Language) speakers. It explains why you are wrong, which helps you learn. ProWritingAid can be a bit overwhelming if you aren’t fluent.

4. What about security?

Grammarly is a cloud-based keylogger effectively. They have strong security, but if you are a lawyer or working on sensitive docs, turn it off. Hemingway’s desktop app works offline, which is the safest option.

Final Verdict: The Winner Is…

Here is my recommendation:

• Get Grammarly (Free) immediately. Install the Chrome extension. It’s a no-brainer.
• If you blog or write copy: Bookmark Hemingway Editor and use it for every post. Aim for Grade 8 readability.
• If you are writing a book: Buy ProWritingAid (Lifetime Deal). It pays for itself in one manuscript.

Writing is hard. Editing is harder. Use the robots to do the heavy lifting so you can focus on the ideas.

🔗 Recommended Tools: Hostinger Hosting | NordVPN | VideoExpress AI